Playing11 min read

Kings Pawn Opening: 2.Nf3 Leads at Every Rating, the King's Gambit Climbs

Most pages on the King's Pawn Opening list Black's replies to 1.e4. None gives engine scores or human frequencies for White's next move. Chessdrive's Maia3 and Stockfish data covers 1.e4 e5 at seven rating bands. 2.Nf3 is the engine's top move (+0.30) and the likeliest human move at every band, from 57.3 percent at 1000 to 71.4 percent at 2200. 2.Qh5 fades after 1200, while 2.f4, the King's Gambit, rises to 11.3 percent at 2000 even though the engine puts it 0.64 in Black's favour. This page is the hub for every second move, with links to the full guides.

The starting position

The kings pawn opening usually means 1.e4, the first move that opens lines for the bishop and queen and controls d5 and f5. Whether it is the best first move in chess is a separate question, and the engine calls it a tie with 1.d4 and 1.Nf3. Wikipedia and chess.com define it that way, and Wikipedia adds that the name is rarely used for the actual opening, because nearly every 1.e4 line has a name of its own. The narrower meaning is the King's Pawn Game: 1.e4 e5, the Open Game, where Lichess and ECO's C20 code use the same words. This page uses both. It treats 1.e4 as the family, then spends most of its space on 1.e4 e5, because that is where White faces the most choices and where our data sits.

Most pages we read list Black's replies. Wikipedia ranks them without figures, chess.com names four, and World Chess gives a table of six. Wikipedia's Open Game page names White's second moves, but none gives engine scores or says what players of different strength actually choose after 1.e4 e5. We ran the maia3-5m checkpoint (see how Maia chess actually works) on two positions at seven rating bands from 1000 to 2200 and graded every legal move with Stockfish 18. The percentages are the model's predicted move probabilities for a player at that rating. They are not database frequencies and not win rates.

Evaluations are from White's side, so +0.30 means White is better by 0.30 pawns. A negative number for White is written as "in Black's favour". The two positions are the one after 1.e4 e5 (the early position) and the one after 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 (the late position), both with White to move. Line checks are separate local Stockfish runs at 10 seconds a position, reaching depths of 18 to 27. Treat any gap under about 0.15 pawns as a tie.

What Black does against 1.e4

As of 28 October 2026, the Lichess page for 1.e4 lists Black's replies by share of games: 1...e5 at 40 percent, 1...c5 at 18, 1...d5 at 11, 1...e6 at 10 and 1...c6 at 8. The page does not label its two score columns, gives no counts, and we could not see which rating or speed filter was on, so read these as online play on Lichess. Wikipedia, using ChessBase data on FIDE-rated games, puts 1...c5 first as of October 2026 and 1...e5 second, and calls the Sicilian the most common continuation in modern practice. Wikipedia's Open Game article adds that 1...e5 led for centuries until the Sicilian became slightly more popular among tournament players in the mid twentieth century.

These do not conflict. Master games lean to the Sicilian and online games lean to 1...e5. The engine barely cares: our local check gives 1...c5 +0.40, 1...e5 +0.36 and 1...c6 +0.27 for White, all within 0.13 pawns of each other, so no reply refutes 1.e4. The replies map to named pages: 1...c5 is the Sicilian Defense, 1...e6 the French Defense, 1...c6 the Caro-Kann Defense, 1...d5 the Scandinavian Defense, 1...Nf6 the Alekhine Defense and 1...d6 with ...g6 the Pirc Defense. For how these choices change with strength, see chess openings by rating.

After 1.e4 e5: the second move

Wikipedia lists White's second moves as 2.Nf3 (the main line and the most popular), 2.Bc4 (Bishop's Opening), 2.Nc3 (Vienna Game), 2.f4 (the King's Gambit) and 2.d4 (Center Game). Here are the five likeliest moves in our early position at each band, with Stockfish's score for White.

Rating1000120014001600180020002200
2.Nf3 (+0.30)57.3%62.4%62.8%61.9%61.7%64.6%71.4%
2.Bc4 (+0.07)9.5%10.8%11.7%11.3%9.6%7.1%4.9%
2.Nc3 (+0.15)7.0%6.5%6.6%6.8%6.8%6.9%7.6%
2.d4 (Black +0.10)6.8%6.1%5.5%5.5%6.0%6.9%6.2%
2.Qh5 (Black +0.41)8.4%3.7%not top fivenot top fivenot top fivenot top fivenot top five
2.f4 (Black +0.64)not top fivenot top five5.1%7.9%10.9%11.3%8.1%

Three things stand out. First, the main move is also the best move. 2.Nf3 is the engine's top choice at +0.30 and the likeliest human move at all seven bands, rising from 57.3 percent at 1000 to 71.4 percent at 2200. Because it is also the engine's top move, the share of players finding the best move equals its share. Second, the weak moves thin out. 2.Qh5 is the third most likely move at 1000 (8.4 percent), falls to 3.7 percent at 1200, and is outside the top five from 1400 up. Third, and less expected, 2.f4 goes the other way. It is not in the top five at 1000 or 1200, then reaches 5.1 percent at 1400, 10.9 percent at 1800 and 11.3 percent at 2000, even though the engine scores it 0.64 in Black's favour, the worst of the six moves in the table. Stronger players do not avoid the risky gambit. They choose it more often, probably because they trust themselves to handle the complications. By 2200 it eases to 8.1 percent as the share of 2.Nf3 grows.

The prediction is what a model says a player at that rating would do, not a count of games. We have no results by rating for these moves, so we cannot say whether 2.f4 scores well at 2000 in practice.

2.Nf3: the main line and the fork on move three

After 2.Nf3 the natural reply is 2...Nc6, and the late position is where White picks the opening's name. Chess.com says 3.Bc4 is the Italian and 3.Bb5 the Ruy Lopez. The engine ranks them close together.

Rating1000120014001600180020002200
3.Bc4 (+0.23)41.3%44.3%45.2%45.1%44.6%42.3%36.7%
3.Bb5 (+0.28)17.2%21.3%23.0%23.5%25.2%30.2%37.8%
3.d4 (+0.13)14.5%14.6%16.1%17.7%18.1%17.0%15.7%
3.Nc3 (+0.13)18.3%12.7%9.2%7.2%5.9%5.5%6.2%

3.Bc4 is the likeliest move from 1000 through 2000, between 41.3 and 45.2 percent. Only at 2200 does 3.Bb5 edge ahead, 37.8 percent to 36.7 percent. The engine does prefer 3.Bb5, at +0.28 against +0.23, but that is a gap of 0.05 pawns. It is a tie, so choosing the Italian over the Ruy Lopez is a matter of style, not a mistake. The Ruy Lopez's share climbs steadily with rating, from 17.2 percent at 1000 to 37.8 percent at 2200, which fits its reputation as the choice of players who want a long manoeuvring game. 3.d4 is the Scotch Game and holds a steady 14.5 to 18.1 percent. 3.Nc3 usually leads to the Four Knights after 3...Nf6 and loses ground from 18.3 percent at 1000 to 5.5 percent at 2000. It matches 3.d4 at +0.13.

The Italian Game and the Ruy Lopez have pages of their own with the third and fourth moves in detail. After 3.Bc4 Bc5, a local check at depth 27 puts 4.c3 at +0.27, 4.d3 at +0.25 and 4.O-O at +0.25, all level. The sharper 4.b4 is the Evans Gambit, a gambit sideline of this position. Black's other main choice at move two is 2...Nf6, the Petrov Defense, and 2...d6 is the Philidor Defense. White's quieter third move 3.c3 is the Ponziani Opening. In our late position, 3.c3 sits in the fifth slot at 2.4 to 4.1 percent and scores 0.21 in Black's favour, which is why it is the rarer choice.

2.Bc4: the Bishop's Opening

2.Bc4 is the second likeliest move from 1000 to 1600, peaking at 11.7 percent at 1400 and fading to 4.9 percent at 2200. The engine scores it +0.07, still slightly better for White but 0.23 below 2.Nf3. A local check on 2...Nf6 3.d3 shows Black's best reply 3...c6 leaving White ahead by 0.11, with 3...Bc5 at +0.20 and 3...Nc6 at +0.28. White keeps a small edge in all three and Black has no problems. The move is a safe way to reach Italian structures while sidestepping the Petrov, but it gives up about a quarter of a pawn against 2.Nf3.

2.Nc3: the Vienna Game

2.Nc3 is steady at 6.5 to 7.6 percent across all seven bands, and the engine scores it +0.15, the second best of the second moves. It is not a surprise weapon at any rating. After 2...Nf6, the sharp 3.f4 is the Vienna Gambit. A local check puts Black ahead by 0.21 with 3...d5, while the greedy 3...exf4 still leaves White ahead by 0.78, so the right answer exists but the wrong one costs. 3.f4 is the move to study before you play it. The quieter 3.Bc4 and 3.g3 are less risky, though we did not check them.

2.f4: the King's Gambit

The King's Gambit sacrifices a pawn for the f-file and the centre. It is one of the sharpest lines after 1.e4 e5, and our data shows the price: 2.f4 is rated 0.64 in Black's favour, the worst score in our early table. A local check on 2...exf4 3.Nf3 finds Black's best reply 3...g5 at 0.69 in Black's favour, with 3...d6 at 0.65. Black keeps the pawn and a clear advantage. The gambit works by making the defender find those moves over the board, and the climb from 5.1 percent at 1400 to 11.3 percent at 2000 says stronger players are willing to try. Our King's Gambit guide by rating follows it to move five at every band. If you plan to play it, expect to prepare more than for any other second move.

2.d4: the Center Game and the Danish Gambit

2.d4 is the Center Game, and 5.5 to 6.9 percent of predicted moves at every band choose it. The engine puts it 0.10 in Black's favour in the early position, so it is not a bad try. A local check on 2...exd4 3.Qxd4 Nc6 4.Qe3 shows Black's best reply 4...Nf6 giving Black 0.23, and 4...Be7 equal at 0.00, so the queen's early excursion costs time without costing material. If you like the central break, compare it with the Scotch Game, which plays d4 after 2.Nf3 Nc6 and keeps a developed knight. The Danish Gambit is the pawn-sacrificing branch of 2.d4 for players who prefer open play.

2.Qh5: the Parham Attack and the Scholar's Mate trap

2.Qh5 is the Parham Attack, also called the Danvers Opening. It attacks the e5 pawn at once, which is why beginners meet it. In our early position it is 0.41 in Black's favour, and a separate local check at depth 20 puts 2...Nc6 at 0.34 in Black's favour. Wikipedia names 2...Nc6 as Black's most frequent reply and gives the main line 3.Bc4 g6 4.Qf3 Nf6 5.Ne2 as one where "White is not worse, but also has no advantage". Our engine disagrees slightly: after 5.Ne2, the best move is 5...Bg7, and the position is 0.38 in Black's favour at depth 22. White is not losing, but Black is the one with the small edge. Wikipedia does not call 3...g6 a trap, and we found none.

The traps are these.

  • 2...Nc6 3.Bc4 Nf6?? loses to 4.Qxf7#. This is Scholar's Mate, and it ends the game on move four.
  • 2...g6?? allows 3.Qxe5+, which our engine rates at +4.91 for White, a rook and pawn up in Wikipedia's account.
  • 2...Ke7?? allows 3.Qxe5#, per Wikipedia. We did not run that line.
  • 2...Nf6 is the Kiddie Countergambit, which gives up the e5 pawn. After 3.Qxe5+ Be7 our check still puts Black ahead by 0.20 against White's best move 4.Qf4, so the engine finds the pawn sacrifice sound.

Do not take this for a threat to an alert player. It rewards an opponent who falls for a trap, and the model puts it outside the top five from 1400 up.

2.Ke2: the Bongcloud

Moving the king on move two is a joke opening, and the engine agrees. After 1.e4 e5 2.Ke2, Stockfish's best reply is 2...Nf6, which leaves Black ahead by 1.65 pawns at depth 20, with 2...d5 at 1.52 and 2...Bc5 at 1.44. Every reasonable reply gives Black well over a pawn. It is a good way to lose a rated game, and a fine way to play a friend.

Which opening in this family fits you

Our data has no results by rating, so this is a guide to what the model and the sources suggest, not a score table.

  • Learning 1.e4 as White, around 1000 to 1400. Play 2.Nf3 and then choose between 3.Bc4 and 3.Bb5. They are equal in our data, so pick the one whose plans you enjoy. Read the Italian Game or the Ruy Lopez first.
  • Wanting open lines early. The Scotch Game opens the centre at once. The Evans Gambit and the Danish Gambit sacrifice pawns for speed, and they suit players who like to attack.
  • Around 1600 to 2000. Expect more King's Gambit than you would think, and prepare 2...exf4 3.Nf3 g5 before you meet it.
  • 2200 and above. 2.Nf3 is 71.4 percent of predicted moves, and the Ruy Lopez narrowly becomes the likeliest third move. Know the main lines of both.
  • As Black against 1.e4. Pick 1...e5 if you like open tactical games, or a defence from the list above if you prefer a different structure. Fine's 1941 advice to play only 1...e5, quoted second-hand on a Lichess forum, is not engine-backed: the Sicilian is just as sound.

Where other resources are better

This page is a hub, not a repertoire. The dataset covers 1.e4 e5 and 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6 only, and stops at move three, so it says nothing about the Sicilian, the French or any other reply to 1.e4. For those lines, use the guide linked above or a course. Maia3 5m is a small model of human choice, so its percentages are predictions. Our Stockfish checks are single 10 second runs, not a repertoire book. Wikipedia is better for history, ECO ranges and named lines. Chess.com's page gives a plain tour of the replies. The Lichess explorer has real game counts by rating and speed, which we have not reproduced here. Wikipedia also attributes the phrase "best by test" to Fischer; we found no primary source for it. None of the pages we did read connects each second move to an engine score and to the rating curve, which is the gap this one fills.

What to take from it

The King's Pawn Opening means 1.e4, and the King's Pawn Game usually means 1.e4 e5. After 1.e4 e5, 2.Nf3 is both the engine's top move at +0.30 and the likeliest human move at every band, from 57.3 percent at 1000 to 71.4 percent at 2200. 2.Qh5 fades after 1200, but 2.f4 climbs to 11.3 percent at 2000 despite a score 0.64 in Black's favour. After 2.Nf3 Nc6, 3.Bc4 leads from 1000 through 2000 and 3.Bb5 only edges ahead at 2200, 37.8 percent to 36.7 percent, over a gap of 0.05 pawns that you can ignore. Read the percentages as the predictions of a model, not as a count of real games.

Frequently asked

What is the King's Pawn Opening?
Most sources mean 1.e4, White's king pawn two squares forward. Wikipedia and chess.com both define it that way, and Wikipedia adds that nearly every 1.e4 line has a more specific name, so the label itself is rarely used. Lichess and ECO use the same words for the narrower 1.e4 e5, which ECO files under C20 as the catch-all for unusual moves.
What is the difference between the King's Pawn Opening and the King's Pawn Game?
Wikipedia treats them as synonyms for 1.e4. In practice the King's Pawn Game is also used for 1.e4 e5, which is the Open Game. This page covers 1.e4 as the family and uses our data for the 1.e4 e5 branch, where White chooses a second move.
Is 1.e4 the best first move?
It is the most popular, according to Wikipedia, and the engine has no complaint. In our local Stockfish check, Black's three best replies to 1.e4 (1...c5, 1...e5 and 1...c6) leave White ahead by 0.40, 0.36 and 0.27 pawns. Treat 1.d4 as a matter of taste, not a correction.
What is the best second move after 1.e4 e5?
2.Nf3, at +0.30 for White in our Stockfish 18 data. 2.Nc3 follows at +0.15 and 2.Bc4 at +0.07. Maia3 also predicts 2.Nf3 as the likeliest human move at every rating from 1000 (57.3 percent) to 2200 (71.4 percent).
Is 1...e5 or 1...c5 the most popular reply to 1.e4?
It depends on the population. Wikipedia, citing ChessBase data on FIDE-rated games, puts 1...c5 first. As of 28 October 2026, the Lichess page for 1.e4 shows 1...e5 at 40 percent and 1...c5 at 18 percent, from Lichess games under a rating and speed filter we could not read. Master play and online play differ, so there is no single ranking.
Is 2.Qh5 a good move?
Not really. Our dataset rates it 0.41 in Black's favour, and 2...Nc6 gives Black 0.34 in a separate local check. It is a sensible try against a player who might blunder, and Hans Ree called it provocative but quite sensible, but 2...Nc6 3.Bc4 Nf6?? 4.Qxf7# is the best-known trap.
What are the main lines of the King's Pawn Opening?
For 1.e4 e5 2.Nf3 Nc6, the three main third moves are 3.Bc4 (Italian Game), 3.Bb5 (Ruy Lopez) and 3.d4 (Scotch Game). Against other first replies, 1...c5 is the Sicilian, 1...e6 the French and 1...c6 the Caro-Kann. This page links to a full guide for each.

Want to play 1.e4 against a model that answers like your rating?

Chessdrive runs the real maia3-5m checkpoint on-device as your opponent at any rating you set from 600 to 2600, so you can open with 1.e4 and meet the replies a player at your band actually chooses, then see where the game turned with a separate Stockfish review. Available now on iOS.

Keep reading

All guides

Updated